After being congratulated, Carton asks me to dinner with him, which is a little conspicuous if you ask me. While out on a dinner with him, we share a few drinks together. After getting tipsy, I'm pretty sure I don't like him and I definitely know that he doesn't like me, which might be because we both like Lucie Manette. Since he seems so anry and all depressed, I kindly ask him why he's in such a mood. He says it's because he's a miserable grudge and that he has been worthless all his life.